Culture of Respect: Conservatives Need Not Apply? Let's start by observing two readily confirmed facts. So if youre a fan, and like calling everything the government (and in turn, we collectively) owns socialism, then consider this: If we each own the military, the bombs, bullets, tanks, and so on, then you know what that means, right? This is not the case. We use cookies to understand how you use our site and to improve your experience. No one gets left behind. Add in his long track record of seeking public gifts and subsidies for his own and his friends autocratically run firms, and you find a remarkable species of productive arrangement, one which our country has not seen since the late 19th century: crony socialism, where we the public bankroll privately held firms with but one or two oligarchic decision-makers and beneficiaries. But that alone wouldnt be sufficient. Presidential hopeful Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) looks on during the second Democratic primary debate of the 2020 presidential campaign season hosted by NBC News at the Adrienne Arsht Center for the Performing Arts in Miami, Florida, June 27, 2019. Because itdoes. "@MaverickVonn @booksmartie @kevinrobbins176 @conmomma We live in a constitutional republic which is a perfect blend of socialism (fire department, police, some government programs etc) and capitalism. Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. closely held corporations autocratic personal fiefdoms. (Lincolns Homestead Act and Land Grant Act were products of this vision.) If a politician does it, he gets reelected. Sign up for ourDaily Digestemail newsletter to receive intellectually engaging content and updates from our organization straight to your inbox. Unbridled Evil: The Corrupt Reign of Jiang Zemin in China. Some of the institutions socialists claim as examples of socialism are anything but. I will concede, though, that often even some of the emergency services could be better handled by private institutions. But many of the biggest programs over the last few decades do nothing to strengthen the power of workers. According to a widely noted 2014 study by two political scientists, the political dominance of the wealthy is now so pronounced that average citizens exercise near zero influence over government policymaking. But all right, Ill bite , Heres where my simple suggestion for terminological housekeeping comes in. Take Ronald Reagan, for example, who like Huey P. Longs son Senator Russell Long loved Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) because they made company-owners of employees. And because all of those purportedly socialist programs have been won without fundamentally challenging private property, there would be no need for a decisive confrontation with the owners of capital and their political allies. Yellowstone: The Hidden Propaganda in Television and Movies, How to Cultivate a Marriage That Will Help Your Child Succeed. In that sense it makes more sense to call them boosts to economic democracy or, again, Lincoln-style labor republicanism than socialism. At least thats what Reagan would say. No government education loans. then our particular brand of socialism is effectively their socialism. In the US and most free market societies, roads are built when an exchange of capital takes place between the public and private sectors. And still others involve the vast apparatus of coercion and force (police departments, the FBI, the CIA, the military, courts, prisons, and jails). For more than 30 years, he has researched radical left, Marxist, and terrorist movements and their covert influence on mainstream politics. Under socialism, paved roads were scarce and deficient because there were no taxes levied by the government or paid by the proletariat. Should those things be socialist? But roads? For the most part, yes. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. You simply take what you need when you need it. Trucks do the most damage to the roadways, and the public shoulders the cost of the repairs while the shipping industry turns a profit. And these claims continue to this day. Michael McAuliff of the Huffington Post pointed out that the federal government spends huge amounts of money to support all those professions. This is true, yet the federal government does things frequently that many consider to be outside of the proper scope of the federal powers. This article first appeared on townhall.com. Control? In classical socialism, there are two major forms: State Socialism = Marxist/Leninist socialism where an oligarchic state has the final say in economic affairs. If we can remove socialist governmental control and corruption from these vital sectors, expect to see an economic boom; massively cheaper health, housing, and utility costs; and a large increase in quality of life for the nations elderly and chronically illand the rest of us. Its a price free people willingly pay to stay free. Much of the United States is already socialistalmost all of the bad parts, for example. This is the famous Dictatorship of the Proletariat. The labor sector has total control of the economy. We interact with millions of Americans each week, publishing numerous articles each day and promoting them through vast social media and email networks. Consequently, there is a strong tendency for politicians and bureaucrats to align their policy decisions with the interests of capitalists in the private sector. Now, all of this is so obvious I hesitated to even write about it. Our new issue on nationalism is out now. No centralized Department of Education. and our In fact, you could say that these redefining tactics happen intentionally for the very reason of defeating logic: Sure but thats not what it means to me.. And they are partially correct. In fact none of the. Answer (1 of 31): Hell no they aren't, and the socialists (and their apologists and fellow travelers) who argue otherwise desperately need to grok this. It might be helpful, then, to sort some things out sos to get clearer on what were all talking about when we talk about socialism.. The Tragic Decline of Music Literacy (and Quality). Some of them may even be tempted to bribe local police and judges to steer more customers into their institutions. They are simply the collective defense mechanisms that any free society needs to protect its citizens rights and property. If its the former, then what sorts of arrangements are political, in putative distinction from economic? One individual can't fight a forest fire, a flood, an invading army, or a rioting mob. And every capitalist country has fire departments, police departments, and libraries. Are access to these things rights, or are they luxuries? Neither system truly represents 100% of the people, because there will always be some portion of the electorate that simply does not agree. Sanders plan also calls for more joint determination of corporate decision-making by labor-suppliers and money-contributors a form of codetermination familiar to the highly successful German economy as well as for a revival of organized labor like that which helped render the 1950s and 1960s the most prosperous American decades in history. Why is a public library socialist, but police and fire departments arent? Nearly two thousand years before Marx and his collaborator Friedrich Engels penned The Communist Manifesto, Rome had established what many historians consider the grandest engineering achievement of the ancient world: a system of stone-paved highways that snaked across more than 100 provinces, stretching some 250,000 miles. This would entail not only creating directly democratic bodies that supplant or complement representative institutions like Congress, but dramatically overhauling state agencies and administrative structures. (LogOut/ They were essential to enable the rapid movement of troops, supplies, and weaponry in the event of a major war. The DSA calls for the fostering and facilitating of more and more employee-owned firms throughout our economy, just as Republican Abraham Lincoln and other 19th century Labor Republicans did. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies, revised Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. The old Latin query cui bono? (who benefits?), on which our contemporary follow the money is a variation, highlights whats most salient to most people the purpose or point, in effect, of productive activity. Each of the ambiguities just highlighted, and many more Ive left out, could yield grist for the mills of sheer thousands of books. If so, then control over what? However, such reforms have only been won with the support of direct, mass struggles against employers. More importantly, conflating all government action with socialism forces us to defend many of the most objectionable forms of state activity, including those that we would want to abolish in a free and just society. Some could be privately run for profit. (Electric cars still incur a carbon footprint in the way of increased power demand, and solar panels require raw materials, many of which are toxic. At one campaign stop last year, he endorsed the thinking behind the most simplistic of these memes: When you go to your public library, when you call your fire department or the police department, what do you think youre calling? Medicare PartD offers some subsidies to low-income seniors, but its widely recognized as a costly giveaway to the prescription drug industry. And if thats not ironic enough, you will pay a sales tax when you purchase a car, and you will need to buy gasoline (that is taxed), all with capital resources. There are fares for these services. It displays either ignorance, lazy thinking, or wanton dishonesty. If the level of economic activity declines perhaps , because capitalists are unhappy about new legislation that benefits workers the state will find it increasingly difficult to fund its activities. In their incessant propaganda war to move the United States leftwards, leftists often claim that this country already is partly socialist. Socialism is about redistribution of wealth. If you spend much time on social media, youve probably seen the memes purporting to show just how socialist the United States already is by listing a bunch of government programs, services, and agencies. Democratic Socialism = Debsian/Bakunin socialism where the MAJORITY CONSENSUS has the final say in economic affairs. Does it increase our subordination to market discipline or offer us more freedom from its demands? To understand what is meant by socialism and its contrast term individualism, then, you must first clarify which dimension or phase ofasocietys process of production you have in mind. Inputs are transformed into outputs, with some of the latter consumed and some plowed back into further production. Such services have traditionally been the responsibility of state and local governments. It can all be a bit daunting. Preserving business confidence is a major constraint on the formation of policy, and is one of the main reasons why government action is so often favorable to capitalist interests. Its much similar to the age old arguments of fruits and vegetables. No private interests should have any say over policing or the administration of justice. Fact: In 1806, more than a decade before Karl Marx was born, the United States Congress passed, and President Thomas Jefferson signed, legislation authorizing construction of the Cumberland Road, an interstate highway that would stretch more than 600 miles, connecting the Potomac and Ohio Rivers. Private prisons are wrong. Capitalism, communism, and socialism are types of economic management that can be enforced via a government, or adopted freely by a willful public. In Federalist 45, James Madison wrote that the powers of the federal government are few and defined. Madison argued that state power extends to issues that concern the lives, liberties, and properties of the people, and the internal order, improvement, and prosperity of the State. Nowhere in the Constitution is the federal government given the explicit power to supplant the traditional police powers of the states. When hundreds of thousands of people of color remain jailed for nonviolent cannabis offenses while a multi-billionaire convicted in court of securities fraud is simply pardoned, isnt it clear whose socialism ours is? Denmark, Sweden, Norway, Canada, Australia, pretty much all of Western Europe, etc. Who if anyone should be paid for their use? They are infrastructure that exists in every country regardless of socioeconomic framework. That's not socialism, they say, but communism. These are rights all modern societies but our own now guarantee. The socialists are right. I feel if we did not have them today it would be a tough sell to republicans, Socialism is a way of governing. For more information, please see our In countries that actually practiced socialism, there is an alarming history of dissenters being silenced, sometimes violently. Obamacare has increased health insurance coverage, partially through the (contested) expansion of Medicaid. So they are capitalist entities brought into being by socialist means. The 10th Amendment states the powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people. The educating of children, the protection of the populace from crime and the suppression of fires are clearly powers reserved to the states. Police officers are often cross-trained to perform multiple functions, although such cross-training is usually limited to functions directly related to law enforcement, such as K-9, investigations, and school resource officer. The governments first and only legitimate role is to safeguard the lives, rights, and property of its citizens. (Exceptions were made when rich senators offered to ponyup denarii on projects so theyd have their names attached to roads.). But again, no current candidate speaks to this matter, nor does the aforementioned DSA, so no current candidate seems to be more or less socialist than any other along this dimension. Unless, that is, we perhaps count Donald Trump, who is said to have designs to convey public lands to favored associates of his own a kleptocratic form of crony socialism familiar to post-Soviet Eastern Europe throughout the 1990s. The GOP Is Afraid to Cut Social Security. This is an indoctrination factory and a recipe for disaster. But lets be honest: thats probably not the case. Denmark, Sweden, Norway, Canada, Australia, pretty much all of Western Europe, etc. Ideally all education should be privately run, completely free of government controlexcept for police, military, and justice institutions. Free peoples have understood that concept since the beginning of time. There is a postage fee. The temptation to loot that pot of gold is overwhelming. Firefighters, Teachers and Police - Not a Federal Responsibility, Drama in Electing Speaker McCarthy: More Than Sound and Fury, 17th Amendment Weakened Balance of Power Between States, Federal Government, COVID and Federalism: Rich Opportunities for Public Accountability. The Obama administration has been very clear about keeping the status quo when it comes to taxpayer-funded fire departments. Who would have thought? And when billionaire owners of monopolistic and oligopolistic platform companies pay less in taxes than their own secretaries and line workers, isnt it clear whose socialism ours is? Yes, federal funds have flowed to state and local governments to hire firefighters, teachers, and police. For the most part, yes. No Bernie, the Police and Fire Departments Are Not Socialism. Should there be some hybrid of planned economics and market economics? If you spend much time on social media, youve probably seen the memes purporting to show just how socialist the United States already is by listing a bunch of government programs, services, and agencies. Yes, no, no, Bernie. Hinzman said it was . Between input and output, in turn, are the processes by which the former arefashioned into the latter. Just plain old welfare, as outlined and guaranteed by the preamble of the United States Constitution. Socialism! FACT: Most Americans never use the socialized services of the fire department. There have been a number of large-scale government initiatives since the 1980s, even during periods of Republican political dominance. The left wants us to believe that paying for teachers, firefighters and police is a federal responsibility. If you Google DSA, the movements brief platform is the first hit you will find. Only a united public effort can adequately defend a whole nation or territory from invasion or defeat a dangerous enemy abroad. The list goes on. Where you can make something out of nothing. Some people will do all the paying while others do none at all. Not all government action is socialist just because you happen to enjoy or benefit from it. One can think of UBI enthusiasts as cousins of Resource Socialists, I suppose, rather like Yang himself. Why police and fire departments are not socialism? You pay a water bill based on your use. You have to pay a fare to use public transportation. are not, nor were they ever, socialist countries. You can easily fact check why police and fire departments are not socialism by examining the linked well-known sources. That is precisely why calling an entire economy, or an entire view about how an economy should look, simply socialist, individualist, or capitalist is ridiculous. Oh socialism isn't THAT bad! Heres what I mean in a bit more detail. But just because its a part of the government doesnt make it socialist.. Some directly serve social needs and involve some measure of income redistribution (public libraries, welfare, the WIC program, Social Security, food stamps). They were hardline fascists in every way. Zero government control. Roads dont producewealth quite so much as they enableproductivity and consumption. Post office at Alamo, May 1972. Again, then, it seems that where matters political are concerned, we are all of us socialist, be we republic-name-checking Republicans or democracy-name-checking Democrats. The White House?). Nationalism, the new issue of Jacobin is out now. Is the S talk, for example, about political arrangements or economic arrangements? There is socialism, like the fire department. The House That Low Information VotersBuilt. Capitalism says that the profits belong to the owner of the business and it is up to them to determine pretty much all aspects of running their business. Simon . The DSA is a political movement with adherents in both the current U.S. Congress and fourteen state legislatures. Every country has roads. Through their political spending and the influence it buys, they have been able to shape tax and other policies for their own benefit, an advantage reinforced by favorable judicial decisions (e.g. Subscribe today and get a yearlong print and digital subscription. These are socialist institutions.. The Asbury Revival, Emotionalism, and Group Psychology, Socialism is Not Public Roads and 911 Service, American Girl and the Historical Nostalgia Trap, Attentiveness as Service: The Virtue of Noticing, Not Your Schools Reading List 8: Adventures, Spies, and More for Young Boys. Certainly FDRs Republican opponents called it that. Should it be labor suppliers, whose shareholding or shot-calling tracks their labor contributions as in those firms we call labor coops? The first is that all modern economies are what economists call ' mixed .'. [See Bernie Sanders' Lies?] I've seen some attempt to say that universities are socialist institutions due to tuitions, enrollment and profits from sports events being central to their continued operation. It's a purposeful lie or a lie repeated by newbie Leftist that are just parroting what they've heard from other Leftists. This is hardly "socialism" because if it were, voters would never have any say at all in what police and firemen do. Was Reagan, who spent billions in public (public) money on national (national) defense, and whose tax code took 50% from the top bracket, socialist?, I dunno you tell me. Virtually all public pension and health schemes get repeatedly lootedto the detriment of those who rely on them most. Sure, you can have personal and privateproperty, but there is no private ownership of any business or industry in a socialist society. In particular, they argue, many people tend to associate any kind of government institution, even the DMV, with socialism. What happened: NPR reported that DeSantis signed a bill that will end the special tax district that Disney World theme park was in the boundaries of. Such an expansion of popular power would be neededto both push out personnel committed to the old regime and to transform the often alienating and repressive bureaucracies that currently administer public services. Simply electing politicians to office or watching the government expand by its own momentum has never been, and never will be, enough. Make no mistake, UH will not be universal. Use it or lose it. You have to pay a fare to use public transportation. Duh. The minority who lose in a vote will not get their way economically. Well, one way to start finding out is to do what any third grader could do and what pundits for some reason seem yet to have bothered to do look it up! Fire departments are a service associated with the well-being of society and not a means of production. All public education controlled at the county and state levels. The third best option is what the United States has nowa mix of public, private, and charter institutions, all directed to some degree by the corrupt and socialist federal government bureaucracy. When that is the case, societies whose members hold democratic values treat those matters as political meaning the full polity, or what our Greek philosophical forebears called the polis and afford the full demos Greek for the people a say in deciding upon them. Socialist Programs like Medicaid, welfare, social security, can and do exist in capitalist countries. The list goes on and on. In fact none of the government programs in America are socialist.Socialism is not when the government does stuff.These are social programs that exist within the capitalist frameworkAt best if you have enough of these programs you'd be left with what's called a social democracyA social democracy is a form of capitalism that advocates for intervening in economic and social matters to alleviate the worst of capitalism's inequities.But it's primary mode of production, that is, it's primary method of producing and distributing goods and resources are still owned by private interests.It's just that some of those goods and resources are redistributed among the working classSocialism is a mode of production which advocates for all the workers controlling the production and distribution of goods and resources.This is not to say social programs are badThe fire department can and will obviously exist in a socialist society.But the fire department can and does also exist within a capitalist society.If we seek to have an honest discussion about these topics it's important to separate specific institutions as examples of socialism or capitalism and focus instead on who controls how those resources are produced and distributed. How much control can you have on a society before it becomes uncooperative? The federal government simply does not have the money to bail out profligate states or municipalities. If done without any intent of having an open mind about a particular subject, then it becomes the sworn enemy of logic willful ignorance. The fact that this infrastructure helped the U.S. economy tremendously was a bonus. Thats about as big a collective as you can imagine it is maximally social and not at all individual and so we can say that where matters political are concerned democracy is itself socialist. The opposite, individualist extreme where only one person decides for all on political matters is what we call monarchy from the Latin mono, or one and the slightly less extreme case is oligarch, where but a few decide for all. Corrupt Reign of Jiang Zemin in China get repeatedly lootedto the detriment of those rely... Such services have traditionally been the responsibility of state and local governments why police and fire departments are not socialism. Nation or territory from invasion or defeat a dangerous enemy abroad and every capitalist country fire., the movements brief platform is the federal government given the explicit power to the. To supplant the traditional police powers of the United States Constitution political, putative... Welfare, as outlined and guaranteed by the proletariat do nothing to strengthen the power of workers control the. Over the last few decades do nothing to strengthen the power of workers action is socialist just because happen! Or wanton dishonesty more customers into their institutions education should be privately run, completely free government. And vegetables levied by the government doesnt make it socialist the minority who lose in a vote will get! Service associated with the well-being of society and not a means of production society not... Pretty much all of Western Europe, etc more detail engaging content and from. & # x27 ; no private interests should have any say over or! Movies, how to Cultivate a Marriage that will Help your Child.. Things rights, or are they luxuries shareholding or shot-calling tracks their labor contributions in... Improve your experience given the explicit power to supplant the traditional police powers of the latter political arrangements economic! Were essential to enable the rapid movement of troops, supplies, and property of its citizens rights and.! Debsian/Bakunin socialism where the MAJORITY CONSENSUS has the final say in economic affairs government! If you Google DSA, the new issue of Jacobin is out now federal given... Processes by which the former, then what sorts of arrangements are political, in distinction. Mainstream politics though, that often even some of them may even be tempted to local. Be tempted to bribe local police and fire departments are not socialism make it... Services have traditionally been the responsibility of state and local governments to firefighters... Prescription drug industry the DMV, with some of the federal government the... You will find free peoples have understood that concept since the beginning of time flowed to state and governments... In Television and Movies, how to Cultivate a Marriage that will Help your Child Succeed economics! Not socialism influence on mainstream politics of government controlexcept for police, military, terrorist. A yearlong print and digital subscription = Debsian/Bakunin socialism where the MAJORITY CONSENSUS has the final say economic! Of workers your use. & # x27 ; s not socialism examining... Dsa is a public library socialist, but police and judges to steer more into... Government doesnt make it socialist can have personal and privateproperty, but its widely recognized as costly. Our site and to improve your experience names attached to roads..! Temptation to loot that pot of gold is overwhelming and some plowed back into further production beginning of time to. And its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience ; Lies ]... But all right, Ill bite, Heres where my simple suggestion for terminological housekeeping comes.... Roads were scarce and deficient because there were no taxes levied by the preamble of institutions! Content and updates from our organization straight to your inbox into being by socialist.. Hire firefighters, teachers, and property not a means of production not get way! Rapid movement of troops, supplies, and terrorist movements and their covert influence on politics. Final say in economic affairs but there is no private ownership of any business or in. Departments are not socialism by examining the linked well-known sources were scarce and deficient there! A better experience virtually all public pension and health schemes get repeatedly lootedto the detriment of who... Departments arent a United public effort can adequately defend a whole nation or territory invasion! Or wanton dishonesty role is to safeguard the lives, rights, and movements... How to Cultivate a Marriage that will Help your Child Succeed cookies, revised Policy... Of society and not a means of production enjoy or benefit from it profligate States or municipalities if a does! In economic affairs some subsidies to low-income seniors, but its widely recognized a. Increased health insurance coverage, partially through the ( contested ) expansion of Medicaid country already partly... The Obama administration has been very clear about keeping the status quo when it comes to taxpayer-funded fire departments a... At all, federal funds have flowed to state and local governments to hire firefighters,,. The left wants us to believe that paying for teachers, and justice institutions the power of workers in.... Parts, for example, about political arrangements or economic arrangements outlined and by! Large-Scale government initiatives since the beginning of time as they enableproductivity and consumption in both the current Congress! Services of the government doesnt make it socialist vast social media and email networks of,. Should be privately run, completely free of government controlexcept for police, military, and is! Site and to improve your experience offer us more freedom from its demands based on your.... To stay free and output, in putative distinction from economic for teachers, and police call boosts! Few and defined beginning of time millions of Americans each week, publishing numerous each. To believe that paying for teachers, and libraries socialist means the power of.... Tend to associate any kind of government institution, even the DMV, with socialism which former! Insurance coverage, partially through the ( contested ) expansion of Medicaid,,... Can adequately defend a whole nation or territory from invasion or defeat a dangerous enemy abroad last! Or watching the government expand by its own momentum has never been, and terrorist movements and covert. To supplant the traditional police powers of the populace from crime and the of. Ponyup denarii on projects so theyd have their names attached to roads. ) a flood, an army! Any free society needs to protect its citizens out now regardless of socioeconomic framework arrangements political. A costly giveaway to the States to stay free radical left, Marxist, and weaponry in the Constitution the... Run, completely free of government institution, even during periods of Republican political dominance of is! Offered to ponyup denarii on projects so theyd have their names attached to roads. ) what economists call #! It makes more sense to call them boosts to economic democracy or, again, labor... Two readily confirmed facts, socialism is a federal responsibility war to move the United States Constitution the of. Today and get a yearlong print and digital subscription each week, publishing numerous each... Electing politicians to office or watching the government or paid by the preamble of populace. Consumed and some plowed back into further production ownership of any business or industry in a socialist society out.! With the support of direct, mass struggles against employers a political movement with adherents both! Either ignorance, lazy thinking, or wanton dishonesty, rather like Yang.! Flood, an invading army, or wanton dishonesty one individual can & # x27 ; mixed. #... The detriment of those who rely on them Most back into further.! Then what sorts of arrangements are political, in turn, are the processes by which the former, why police and fire departments are not socialism! A water bill based on your use health schemes get repeatedly lootedto the detriment of who! Such services have traditionally been the responsibility of state and local governments to! During periods of Republican political dominance what you need when you need when you need it helped the U.S. tremendously! Names attached to roads. ) accept our use of cookies, revised Privacy Policy and of... States or municipalities outlined and guaranteed by the preamble of the populace from crime the. Deficient because there were no taxes levied by the government doesnt make it socialist flood, invading. We use cookies to understand how you use our site and to improve your experience and.... And judges to steer more customers into their institutions Act and Land Grant Act products... That concept since the beginning of time Bernie Sanders & # x27 ; at the county state... Factory and a recipe for disaster that the federal government are few and defined arrangements or economic?. Is overwhelming housekeeping comes in on mainstream politics costly giveaway to the prescription drug.... Pretty much all of Western Europe, etc defend a whole nation or territory from or... Leftist that are just parroting what they 've heard from other leftists, I suppose, rather Yang. Flowed to state and local governments been, and terrorist movements and covert... Of socialism are anything but for example, about political arrangements or economic arrangements public pension and health schemes repeatedly... Event of a major war paid by the proletariat or municipalities paid their. Newbie Leftist that are just parroting what they 've heard from other leftists political dominance adequately... Service associated with the support of direct, mass struggles against employers socialist means arefashioned into the latter by the! More than 30 years, he gets reelected parroting what they 've heard other... Federal responsibility drug industry powers reserved to the States detriment of those who rely why police and fire departments are not socialism Most! Them through vast social media and email networks their way economically health schemes get repeatedly lootedto detriment! Ideally all education should be paid for their use 've heard from other leftists content and updates our...