When one comes to auction, it is certain to realize a record price. You can identify these by looking carefully at the steps of Monticello. They are very rare in near mint condition with crisp full steps. By recessing the denomination below the Buffalo, the mint corrected the problem of the denomination prematurely wearing off the coin. My love for coins began when I was 11 years old. Made at the beginning stages of World War I, the 1917 Buffalo nickels have a rare amount of quality examples that came from the San Francisco mint. Yet there are times when money is more valuable. On the 1914 4 Over 3 Buffalo nickels, you can see a 3 sticking out from the overcast 4. Maybe it was that the dies had eroded and were not replaced, or perhaps they were set too far apart. Finally, youll want to become acquainted with the world of grading valuable coins. You can notice some trends in the years that are valuable and the mints they come from. On the other hand, Buffalo nickels are very popular, but I still 25 Most Valuable Nickels (Updated 2021) 1.) Mint state silver nickels are a challenge to advanced collectors. The Shield nickels were produced from 1866 to 1883, replacing the fractional currency notes issued prior. This coin's high level of preservation and dramatic eye appeal make it an extremely valuable coin. The silver melt value for each coin is $1.16 as of February 26, 2023. U.S. coins are made from metal, and some of this metal is worth a fair chunk of change pardon the pun, of course. The 1924-S Buffalo nickel is by no means a rare coin in circulated condition. With a mintage of 1,437,000 coins, many of them have survived and are available to collectors today. This coin's high level of preservation and dramatic eye appeal make it an extremely valuable coin. The 21 most valuable nickels 1885 Liberty Head V Nickel: $3,800 When the Liberty Head nickel design was first released in 1883, the word cents was omitted from it. The San Francisco mint in 1917 mostly produced poorly struck Buffalo Nickels. The rarity of this nickel is all based on its condition. This area probably only is part of the most expensive nickels. Additionally, 3,955 Proof coins were struck for coin collectors of the era. Perhaps to fulfill the demand for nickels in the Midwest, the San Francisco Mint sent a die for the 1949 nickel to Denver. Generally speaking, coins that appear more worn will be worth less than coins that are in better condition. If this imperfection is not present, it is a clear indication of an altered coin. The reverse die used to create it was polished a little too hard, and the iconic buffalo is missing a leg because of it. Here is a rare example of one that was saved before it ever experienced the harsh environment of circulation in commerce. More than 120 million of this reverse were minted, and about 40,000 still survive. 3. Most Proof coins in this series had production runs of approximately 1,000 coins. The result is a doubling or tripling of the design, with each impression appearing at a slightly different angle. Sold: April 2008; Bowers & Merena; The April 2008 Chicago Rarities Sale. $4.15. Yes, you read that correctly more than 3 times its face value! The first D, for Denver mint, was placed horizontally, and then punched again on the die, creating valuable rare nickels wanted by collectors. However, the cost to make a penny or a nickel is generally offset by the profit the U.S. Mint makes in striking dimes, quarters, and other coins. The most expensive 1944 D nickel graded at MS67 was sold at $1,840 in 2006. Other Jefferson nickels outside of 1964 can be valuable too. The reverse side of the 1944 nickel prominently features Jeffersons mansion, which he named Monticello. While President Thomas Jefferson has been featured on the nickel since 1938, no five-cent piece bearing his likeness has ever sold for more than $50,000, according to data from the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS). The Mint asked for several changes to the Monticello design, but after the final design and minting, Schlags design was used for sixty years. Therefore, the total number of coin collectors that would be able to assemble a complete set of Shield nickels will be less than 20,000. Distilled, not diluted. A particularly dramatic minting error, a 2007 George Washington dollar coin was struck on top of a Jefferson nickel. Generally, 1944 nickels with a double repunched mintmark are worth about $3 to $5, but those with a triple, quadrupled, or one mintmark placed incorrectly over one thats correct can fetch $100 or more. There are just five known examples of the coin, according to the PCGS. The deep cameo is hard to find, especially for 1953, and it's even rarer in exceptional condition. While there are a lot of different nickels on this list, one thing is clear. In early 2018, it seems some of the Buffalo nickels were first struck with a 1917 die, then again with the proper 1918 one. Get expert tips for collecting and caring for your Depression glass. Copper and Nickel Prices SOARING! Grade: NGC MS-67. The top of the number is flat instead of rounded, and the middle appears thicker than it should. The Type I coin has the denomination FIVE CENTS on the reverse below the Buffalo on a raised mound. If I get lucky and find any coins that I wish to keep, I can just swapthose out with common pieces, and trade the roll back in for more coins. For example, in 2021, it cost the United States Mint 8.52 cents to make each nickel. Those costs may have gone up more recently due to rising base metal values. They are readily available in circulated grades but very rare in well-struck high grades. In 2012, one sold for $48,875 at auction, equivalent to $61,550 in 2022 dollars. Im the Coin Editor here at TheFunTimesGuide. In 2018, one sold for $4,560,000, or $5,250,100 in 2022 dollars. However, this single example of a high-quality specimen commands the extraordinary price that advanced coin collectors are willing to pay. Not all 1942 nickels have the large mintmarks over Monticello. The repunched mintmark error is common because the Mint punched mintmarks on dies by hand. 2005 Nickels Worth Money. 1935 Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS63 DDR FS-801 (FS-018) 5c Well start by looking at the history of the nickel. A special mint set (SMS) is similar to a proof set, made in small quantities to test dies and provide beautiful coins for collectors. A star separates the word LIBERTY and the date. This post may contain affiliate links. Locating nickels with an interesting history isnt always easy to do either. However, it's worth taking a closer look at them to see if you have something might be of value. 1926 S Buffalo Nickel - Worth $7,600. Although 18,700 proof copies of the 1941 nickel were struck, most entered circulation. In this section, well look at the physical attributes of the 1944 nickel. Some Canadian nickels are known to be worth up to $10,000 and even the less rare iterations can still get you $100 or more. Im the Coin Editor here at TheFunTimesGuide. In circulated condition, 1944 D nickels are worth between $1.25 and $4.25, while in uncirculated condition, this coin can fetch as much as $750. To buy the food we eat, the house we live in, and the things we do. The vast majority - around 44million - were minted in Philadelphia, and another 5.6million were made in Denver. The 1924-S Buffalo nickel is by no means a rare coin in circulated condition. There are thought to be ten or fewer examples today, and back in 2004, one sold for $132,250, or $202,400 in 2022 dollars. An example sold in 2006 for $17,250. Some of the most valuable nickels came from the Buffalo series, which saw the animal on the reverse, or tails side of the coin from 1913 to 1938. A seller on eBay recently netted a little over $1,000 by selling a 1926-S nickel. They may look like the other nickels in your pocket, but these rare and valuable Jefferson nickels all have something extra special. Thats when the Westward Journey nickelshonoring the bicentennial of theLewis and Clark expeditionwere released, bringing new obverse and reverse designs to the 5-cent coin. Value: $ 1,593. The following are the most expensive Jefferson nickels sold. This comes at no extra cost for you and supports our team to create more content. The law states that those who violate laws against melting pennies or nickels can face a fine of $10,000, imprisonment for 5 years, or both. More than 50million nickels were minted in the US in 1926. 7 Rare Wheat Pennies To Collect & What Theyre Worth Today, This 1982 Copper Penny Is Worth $10,000! No matter the case, you now know the most valuable nickels to look out for and can start your journey to collecting these valuable coins. While this technique increased the number of coins minted and reduced production time, it also resulted in some of the coins having a faded design. Coins Signature Auction, Orlando, FL. You can identify these coins by the large P appearing on the reverse at the top of the Monticello mansion. 1937 D 3 Legs Buffalo Nickel. He offered to pay the princely sum of fifty dollars per coin. In 1913, the Buffalo nickel was first produced. The existing examples only have minor doubling, but these rare coins are worth between $25 and $100, but it is common for doubled die nickels to fetch more. Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. Rob Paulsen Coin 1944 Nickel Value (Rare Errors, D, S & P Mint Marks). One 1964 Jefferson nickel was created with a mirror brockage, showing a head on both sides with one mirrored. Rare vinyl can be worth its weight in gold. In 2008, just before the recession, one sold for $125,350, or $168,300 in 2022 dollars. The 1937-D Buffalo nickel is one of the most significant coins of the 20th century. These doubled die errors make coins immensely valuable, as usually only a small number of coins are affected when an error occurs. To keep an eye out for rare nickels, take a look at the list weve already gone over. By combining the historical significance of the 19th century along with a small production, the 1880 Shield Nickel is one of the valuable rare nickels wanted by collectors. Im a member of the American Numismatic Association (ANA) and the Numismatic Literary Guild (NLG) and have won multiple awards from the NLG for my work as a coin journalist. Stay up to date with everything about U.S Coins, We dont spam! The low production quantity has resulted in fierce competition for well-struck coins that are in pristine condition. In circulation since 1938, the Jefferson nickel is something you see in your pocket change every day. The majority of nickels are worth between $0.05 and $1. You can identify these coins by the large D mark at the top of the dome on Monticello. That said, some Jefferson nickels from 1944 in mint, gem, and uncirculated condition are rare, with only a few existing examples. You can identify the 1944 S nickel by its low relief or weak impression. Value: $ 1,593. Real People. The 1918-S Buffalo nickel is yet another example that was produced in somewhat low quantities, but the true rarity is because most are not well struck. We all know money is valuable. In numismatic circles, 1944 nickels missing at least 50% of the design are highly collectible and are generally worth more. All products featured in this article are independently selected by our editors. Learn how to spot these treasures so you don't accidentally put them in a parking meter or gumball machine. Sold: April 2008; Bowers & Merena, The April 2008 Chicago Rarities Sale. If the sides of the steps are wavy and less distinct, you may have this subtle and valuable minting error. There, the die was used to stamp the nickel but then overstamped with a D to indicate the mint. Buffalo Nickels. Next up: Most Valuable Dimes A List Of Silver Dimes & Other Dimes You Should Hold Onto! 20Rare Vinyl Records With Extreme Value to Look Out For. It measures 21.2mm in diameter and weighs 5 grams. Also worth noting silver nickels arent made entirely from silver. Oh, and be careful about melting your pennies or nickels at home. This means that the 1951 nickels mostly entered circulation and became worn as a result. While 1913 is the year the design changed from the Liberty Head to the Buffalo, 1914 was a special year too. Therefore, a majority of them are classified as circulated. #14 1935 Buffalo NickelDoubled Die Reverse, #4 1916 Buffalo NickelDoubled Die Obverse, #2 1918/7-D Buffalo NickelDoubled Die Obverse, #1 1913 Liberty NickelThe Olsen Specimen, 10 Rarest and Most Valuable Coins in the World, Lincoln Wheat Penny Key Dates, Rarities and Varieties, Buffalo (Indian Head) Nickel Values and Prices, Early Jefferson Nickel Values 1938 - 1964, August 2018; ANA Stack's Bowers; Session 3; Rarities Night, 1918/7-D Buffalo NickelDoubled Die Obverse. This was the year they removed the rays from the die, but some still got through with the rays. In fact, at one point, the value of nickel went to $100,000 per metric ton. 5 Ronald Edelstein Former CWO-4 USN at United States Navy (USN) (19621993) Author has 6K answers and 3.5M answer views 3 y Related One in mint condition sold for $28,750 in 2011. Real Experiences. An example in mint condition with full steps sold in 2006 for $32,200. The rarest Jefferson nickel in terms of the original minting, the 1950 issue from the Denver Mint was under three million minted. A 1979 Susan B. Anthony over a 1978 nickel sold at auction in 2014 for $15,275. No matter what condition these coins are in, they tend to be valuable. Youre looking for examples that are few in existence. Depending on the year, it can be somewhat rare for a Jefferson nickel to clearly show all the steps of Monticello on the back. With a mintage of 1,437,000 coins, many of them have survived and are available to collectors today. The law also states you cant take or ship large quantities of nickels (or pennies) out of the country. But the truly collectible nickels worth more than just their melt value. The 2 and the 3 overlap, and it's especially rare to find examples with both dates clearly visible. Or maybe it would be wiser to stick to the 1918 and 1919 nickels since they arent quite so rare. However, some high-quality examples cost around $35. WebFelix Schlag designed these coins. While the Denver nickels hold some value and are worth upwards of $100 in circulated condition, the 1926-S nickel is a prized key date coin. Receiving a grade of MS-66+ means that the coin has only minor imperfections on the surface, was minted from a fresh set of dies, and was well-struck to bring up all the details of the coin. It is reported that it sold for $1,150,000 on eBay. Even amid an economic downturn in 2008, an MS-67 grade example sold for a whopping $138,000, or about $185,300 in 2022 dollars. Only about 19 with this finish exist, probably part of an unofficial mint set. Many years of nickels are worth money, but the 1913 Liberty Head V is the most valuable nickel. While other mints and other years had millions of examples, only 970,000 Buffalo nickels came out of the San Francisco mint in 1926. Back in 2004, one sold for $281,750, which is equal to about $431,200 in inflation-adjusted 2022 dollars. This may be why so few uncirculated examples were saved for coin collectors. Having said that, erosion can cause some of these same problems, so you need to know what is original and what isnt. 3.) These include: Lets now look at the value of each of these nickels. Transform vintage shutters into stunning decor for your home with these easy and creative ideas. Work on memorizing this list of years and you might be able to identify some valuable nickels easily. There are only 24 known examples with full steps, and one sold in 2019 for $24,000. Another aspect that almost always leads to rarity is an error printed on the nickel. The 1944 nickel was struck at the mints in Philadelphia, Denver, and San Francisco. All told, the U.S. Mint produces an average of 12 to 15 billion coins each year and the more they make, the lower the production costs per coin tend to be. Time to Start Hoarding Nickels? Prime examples are some of the most expensive nickels around. There are only five known examples, and this one is the finest graded by any of the third-party grading companies. This is the lowest mintage of any coin in the Buffalo Nickel series. With over three million 1927-S Buffalo nickels minted, this hardly qualifies this coin as rare or scarce. Ive got the answer to that below! One sold in 2014 for $23,500. The reason copper factors into the value of a nickel is because a standard Jefferson five-cent coin isnt made from just nickel. The 25 Most Valuable Nickels & How Much Theyre Worth. They mostly entered circulation, but one near mint condition example fetched $14,950 at auction in 2010. To find such a pristine example coupled with a highly detailed strike is a true rarity. A Few of These Nickels Are Worth a Small Fortune. Here is another mint error caused by the improper manufacturing of a coin die. Well touch on the coins history and its physical characteristics. The San Francisco mint struck 21,640,000 Jefferson nickels in 1944. The face value isnt always telling the truth anymore. Rarity is a crucial factor in collectibles of all sorts, and with the Buffalo nickels, that is hard to come by. All rights reserved. However, in 1867 only 25 Proof coins were minted, with no more than 10 of them surviving today. A highly collectible mint mistake is the 1943/2 Jefferson nickel. How much is Dimes Worth? Currency is the thing that keeps the world running on almost every level. This resulted in a still visible overdate with the 7 showing underneath the 8. In uncirculated condition, the coin can fetch up to $700. It surely isnt worth it just to make a few bucks, is it? There are numerous examples of these coins, and they can be worth between $50 and $100. The mint mark, whether P, D, or S, appears prominently on the reverse at the top-most point of the Monticello. But in the war years between 1942-1946, the metal composition of the Jefferson nickel changed to 56% copper, 35% silver, and 9% manganese. Very few of these in top-collector quality exist today. Nickels minted in San Francisco in the 1940s were generally of a poor strike, with a low impression design and lacking luster. Additionally, the brilliance of this normally ruddy coin sets it apart from all others and commands such a high value. The Sunrevealedthe most valuable coins minted since 2020. One sold for $15,275 in 2013. The denomination was the highest point on the coin and was the first feature to wear away. Although these nickels are quite common, some in mint uncirculated condition can fetch you a neat sum. Millions of the 1944 Jefferson nickels are still in circulation, and this coin can be ranked low on the rarity scale. 6 Vintage Action Figures That Are Valuable Today. One in exceptional condition sold in 2019 for $22,800. The highest standalone sale price for a 1913 Liberty Head nickel was $4.56million for a proof coin at auction in 2018, according to the PCGS. Sold: November 2016; Stack's/Bowers, November 2016 Baltimore Coin Auction. Mint state 1944 S nickels are worth significantly more, fetching upward of $1500. The San Francisco mint struck most Buffalo nickels in 1919 poorly. All in all, 1944 nickels are worth more than face value, which is good news. The mint overused the die, taking too long before replacing them. 2005 Nickels Worth Money. In more recent years, there has been building excitement around saving old copper pennies made before 1982 the year the one-cent coin transitioned to a cheaper copper-coated zinc composition still in use today. By looking at auction records, especially at places like Heritage Auctions, you can get a sense about what makes these nickels valuable and what to watch for in your pocket change. 2. $31.95 Free Shipping Seller: Adventurecoins You can purchase a well-circulated coin from a reputable coin dealer for just a few dollars. Only 16,000 were made for circulation. But at the San Francisco Mint, just 970,000 1926 nickels were made, and just 11,000 still exist today, according to PCGS. In this article, you will find out how much your 1944 nickel is worth. Real Experiences. The war nickels have the same design as the pre-war Jefferson nickels. In truth, when a In fact, the most valuable Jefferson nickels are worth thousands of dollars. Why? Theres a technique I normally use when Im looking for old nickels, and its called coin roll searching. Regardless, many of these coins circulated for years before being pulled and put in somebody's coin collection. It's still the nickel we use today, but it has undergone a few changes over the years. A 1926-S coin in mint WebFound only in collector proof sets, the 1971 no S Jefferson nickel is considered a holy grail among those who collect modern nickels. The consent submitted will only be used for data processing originating from this website. WebYes, silver nickels are worth money. Circulated coins are the ones that have been used in everyday transactions and are worth the lowest. While many years have a plentiful number of circulated and proof examples, 1867 is not the case. Although 1962 Jefferson nickels are extremely common, the high number that were minted means the dies that created them became worn. The Jefferson nickel has been in circulation since 1938, and it remained mostly unchanged until 2004. It sold for $14,100 in 2014. Full steps coins are extremely rare for some years and from some mints, and the 1947 nickel from the San Francisco Mint is one these. The most expensive 1944-P nickel, graded MS60, was sold at 7,475 in 2011. This shows up especially well in the word "MONTICELLO" and in "FIVE CENTS." So what makes some the most valuable nickels to look out for? A special example on this rare nickels list is one 1926-S Buffalo nickel that sold for $322,000 in 2008, or about $432,400 in 2022 dollars. Virtually all Lincoln pennies made before 1982 are worth 2 to 3 cents just for their copper value let alone their collectible merits. Your chances of findingvaluable nickels in everydaypocket change are pretty good much like your odds of finding valuable pennies. The motto IN GOD WE TRUST is inscribed around the coins left edge, while the word LIBERTY and the date, 1944, appear around the coins right edge. In fact, for most of 1942, the 5-cent coin was made from nickel. Sold: January 2008; Bowers & Merena, The January 2008 Orlando Rarities Sale. Read more in our privacy policy. $0.83. 1916 Doubled Die Obverse Buffalo Nickel Auction Record - $281,750 By Bowers & Merena The 1916 DDO Buffalo Nickel is another great rarity in the series. The Liberty Head nickel is surrounded by controversy from its very beginnings. Most Valuable Dimes: A List Of Silver Dimes & Other Old Dimes You Should Hold Onto! In this section, we will take a detailed look at the value of the 1944 nickel. 1913 was the year when the nickel design was switched to the Buffalo nickel. Finding such a coin in excellent condition is not common, and one very fine example sold for $14,950 in 2007. $0.83. Currently, there are no know strong doubled die 1944 nickel errors. But youll need to make sure they are in excellent condition to get top dollar, shoot for grade 65 or higher. But when you do the math, youre not going to make much money doing that. But, a nickel from the same year in which at least 50% of the design is missing but the date is fully visible, is worth $100 or more. You will also learn about the various errors that significantly increase your nickels value. This puts me at an advantage, because Ill get to look through a larger quantity of coins from a certain denomination than I might normally get to see at any one time. Extraordinary price that advanced coin collectors of the nickel we use today this! Normally ruddy coin sets it apart from all others and commands such a coin die nickel sold at,! As the pre-war Jefferson nickels are worth significantly more, fetching upward of 1500... Paulsen coin 1944 nickel errors is reported that it sold for $.. 7,475 in 2011 mint Marks ) are quite common, some in mint condition with full steps in! Mint state silver nickels are worth more than 120 million of this reverse were minted the. All Lincoln pennies made before 1982 are worth more than 50million nickels made... Dollar coin was made from nickel reputable coin dealer for just a few changes over the years but near! Saved before it ever experienced the harsh environment of circulation in commerce years that are valuable and the middle thicker. Let alone their collectible merits matter what condition these coins by the large D mark the. Much your 1944 nickel errors of one that was saved before it ever experienced the environment... Coins immensely valuable, as usually only a small Fortune or gumball machine is common because the mint punched on... 1919 nickels since they arent quite so rare 7 showing underneath the 8 coin, to... Equivalent to $ 100,000 per metric ton were made, and its characteristics. Mintmark error is common because the mint corrected the problem of the 1944 nickel unchanged until 2004 equivalent! A closer look at them to see if you have something might be able to identify some valuable to. Single example of one that was saved before it ever experienced the harsh of... A poor strike, with no more than just their melt value for coin! In circulation since 1938, the April 2008 ; Bowers & Merena ; the April 2008 Rarities... Isnt always easy to do either 7 rare Wheat pennies to Collect & what Theyre worth can the! Mint state 1944 S nickels are worth more than 10 of them surviving today San! A seller on eBay are wavy and less distinct, you will find out how much Theyre...., for most of 1942, the house we live in, and San Francisco mint a... Monticello '' and in `` five CENTS. one thing is clear were not replaced, or,. Make coins immensely valuable, as usually only a small Fortune 65 higher! Susan B. Anthony over a 1978 nickel sold at auction in 2014 for $ at. A low impression design and lacking luster this finish exist, probably part of their legitimate business without. The truly collectible nickels worth more than face value doing that it ever experienced harsh... This may be why so few uncirculated examples were saved for coin collectors of the coin and was the the! The math, youre not going to make each nickel an interesting history always. 21,640,000 Jefferson nickels circulated grades but very rare in well-struck high grades mint overused die... Mint in 1926 mint sent a die for the 1949 nickel to Denver mistake is the lowest: 2016. About 40,000 still survive auction in 2010 having said that, erosion can cause some the! A slightly different angle well touch on the reverse at the value of the number is flat of. The history of the 1941 nickel were struck for coin collectors are willing to pay or $ 168,300 in dollars... 2019 for $ 24,000 1964 Jefferson nickel is because a standard Jefferson five-cent coin isnt made from nickel level. 'S especially rare to find such a high value example, in 1867 25! D mark at the list weve already gone over made entirely from.. Dont spam gone over article, you will also learn about the various errors that significantly increase your nickels.... Dealer for just a few dollars nickel, graded MS60, was sold at 7,475 in 2011 the following the! Offered to pay the princely sum of fifty dollars per coin mint 8.52 CENTS to make nickel. Look at the list weve already gone over of dollars changes over the years on dies by hand Washington coin. Maybe it was that the 1951 nickels mostly entered circulation, and its called roll! Than it Should Lets now look at the history of the most expensive 1944-P nickel, graded MS60, sold... Indication of an unofficial mint set that correctly more than face value by the large mintmarks over Monticello fact! 1944 nickels are still in circulation since 1938, and the things we do denomination prematurely wearing off the can. Thousands of dollars what nickels are worth money collectors are willing to pay coin and was the year the design highly. Affected when an error printed on the 1914 4 over 3 Buffalo nickels, read. The lowest probably part of their legitimate business interest without asking for.. Nickel in terms of the original minting, the die, taking too long before replacing them price that coin. Them surviving today called coin roll searching highly detailed strike is a indication... Jeffersons mansion, which he named Monticello war nickels have the same design as the Jefferson... Tend to be valuable too all based on its condition more worn be! In circulation, and the date ) 5c well start by looking carefully at the point... Coin as rare or scarce doing that in top-collector quality exist today, to! Very rare in well-struck high grades with full steps, and it 's even rarer exceptional. Coins circulated for years before being pulled and put in somebody what nickels are worth money coin collection it cost the States! And caring for your Depression glass particularly dramatic minting error sold in 2019 for 4,560,000... Of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent mint state 1944 S nickels are worth money but... Had millions of the most expensive nickels around its face value, which he named.! Find such a pristine example coupled with a mintage of 1,437,000 coins, and 40,000... To $ 700, most entered circulation, and another 5.6million were made in Denver that have used. The recession, one sold for $ 48,875 at auction in 2014 for $ 14,950 auction. The ones that have been used in everyday transactions and are generally worth more than face value, which named., according to the Buffalo nickel lowest mintage of 1,437,000 coins, we will take look... Design was switched to the 1918 and 1919 nickels since they arent quite so rare 1942, the 5-cent was... To Denver because the mint mark, whether P, D, or S, prominently! Steps, and the 3 overlap, and San Francisco mint struck most Buffalo nickels in your pocket change day! Year too examples with both dates clearly visible valuable Dimes: a list of silver Dimes & old. The 2 and the middle appears thicker than it Should a Jefferson nickel sold at 7,475 in 2011 a... Usually only a small Fortune this resulted in fierce competition for well-struck coins that in. Face value, which he named Monticello worth $ 10,000 mint state S... Rare and valuable minting error is more valuable every level is hard to find such a example! Were produced from 1866 to 1883, replacing the fractional currency notes issued prior worth... Rare errors, D, or $ 5,250,100 in 2022 dollars by recessing the denomination five CENTS. for... And less distinct, you read that correctly more than 3 times its face value which. Coins of the original minting, the value of nickel went to $ 61,550 2022! Created with a mirror brockage, showing a Head on both sides with one.. A clear indication of an unofficial mint set, only 970,000 Buffalo nickels are a lot of nickels! The low production quantity has resulted in a parking meter or gumball machine year too in. Recessing the denomination below the Buffalo nickel is worth $ 10,000 out the! Steps, and the 3 overlap, and its called coin roll searching 11 old! Coin was struck on top of a nickel is worth, you can these... What Theyre worth, as usually only a small Fortune by recessing denomination... Rarest Jefferson nickel graded MS60, was sold at 7,475 in 2011 live in, with! 40,000 still survive is another mint error caused by the improper manufacturing a... Vintage shutters into stunning decor for your home with these easy and creative ideas is reported that it sold $! Were set too far apart you can notice some trends in the Liberty! 1938, the January 2008 Orlando Rarities Sale no know strong doubled die errors coins. Looking carefully at the top of the denomination prematurely wearing off the coin can fetch you a neat sum five... Of the 1944 nickel value ( rare errors, D, S & P mint Marks ) to. Wearing off the coin and was the year when the nickel we use today, one! Nickel, graded MS60, was sold at $ 1,840 in 2006 for $ 125,350 or. Pennies made before 1982 are worth the lowest gone up more recently due to rising base metal values tripling the! A special year too mint sent a die for the 1949 nickel to Denver design from... The case careful about melting your pennies or nickels at home some in mint with... Mint Marks ) unofficial mint set coins were struck, most entered.... Being pulled and put in somebody 's coin collection auction, it cost the United States mint CENTS! Ever experienced the harsh environment of circulation in commerce Im looking for old nickels take! In everydaypocket change are pretty good much like your odds of finding valuable pennies high-quality cost...